Celebrating Easter in a world turned upside-down

Salt + Light Media invited me to share a reflection for Easter Sunday, based on the Gospel reading. You can read the full version here. 

Noli_me_assisi

“Mary of Magdala came to the tomb early in the morning, while it was still dark, and saw the stone removed from the tomb.”

-John 20:1 

Our experience of Lent this year has been intensified by the distress and restrictions caused by the worldwide pandemic, resulting in a situation many of us would not have imagined six months ago. At the same time, since mid-Lent we have been distanced from Mass and the immersive liturgies for Holy Week. How do we celebrate Easter when our world has turned upside down and we know that the global dark days are not over?

Sharing in the sufferings of the world certainly makes this Easter unique for me, but this is not the first Easter where joyful celebrations have felt out of place or even impossible. Several years ago, my Easter was a time of grief and loss: a close friend had just died of a devastating illness and two family members became seriously ill. Something inspired me to take Saint Mary Magdalene as my guide that Easter, and she has accompanied me through my Lents and Easters ever since. Initially, I chose her because of her immense grief at Jesus’ Crucifixion, but the more I prayed with her, the more I was moved by her relationship with Christ.

Saint Mary Magdalene is the perfect guide through Holy Week and Easter because, even before she met Jesus, she knew darkness and grief on a level that most of us can only imagine: Jesus healed her from seven demons. The Gospels don’t provide any details so we don’t know much about it, but it must have been a terrible experience of darkness.

When Jesus healed her, her desperate soul must have seen the first glimmer of hope—a hope that blossomed as she became Jesus’ follower. We don’t know how long Mary accompanied Jesus during his public life—a month? a year? Maybe long enough for that new, fragile hope to begin to take root in her heart. Nonetheless, her overwhelming sorrow at Jesus’ Crucifixion hints that her Lord’s suffering and death crushed her tender, newfound hope. She comes to visit Jesus’ tomb not because she has hope but because she carries immense grief. (Continue reading here.)

Movies To Uplift Us

I recently read a newsletter from a lovely Christian writer who reflected that everything she saw was about COVID-19. I was struck by what she said, and the next day, I had to agree with her when I  watched the beginning of Frozen II. Yes, I could apply many of the song lyrics to what we are going through now. Would you agree?

What movies can we watch that will help us not only celebrate Easter, but help us as we go through this time? While movies can provide a healthy break from our problems, film is a powerful medium that often can do more than provide a few hours of relief. Movies can uplift us, offer us food for thought, provide hope and insight into our own experiences of darkness, grief, and anxiety.

I’ve had a few Easters where I couldn’t put my heart into singing “Alleluia.” And what always made a difference to me was love: true, self-sacrificing love. I’ve felt blessed when I’ve received that kind of love, or finally recognized that someone loved me that way. I’ve also felt especially blessed when I have deeply loved someone else, to the point that no matter what suffering or challenges I was facing, it was worth it because of that love in my life.

Listen to my Salt + Light Radio Hour about self-sacrificing love in movies with Deacon Pedro here.

Have you ever noticed that in most of the hugely popular films—I’m talking about big hits like Titanic, Twilight, Avengers films, and others—one of the main characters risks or actually sacrifices himself or herself out of love for another? I think these stories are super popular because we’re all drawn to this kind of radiant goodness. And I think all of us want to be loved like that. And want to be persons who love like that. Even if we’re afraid of the sacrifice.

The truth is, of course, that each of us is loved like that. Jesus died for love of each of us. The whole Triduum is about love: God’s love for us, and God’s desire to save us and be united with us here on earth and for all eternity. The love we experience with our loved ones is just a tiny glimmer of the love God has for each of us!

So during this week, I’d like to challenge you to look for these glimmers or reflections of God’s love in what you watch. Below, I’ll share some of my favorite films with this theme. (And if you share some of your favorite films with self-sacrificing love in the comments, via email, or on Facebook, I’ll keep adding what you share to my list!)

Sr. Marie Paul’s Favorite Films with the Theme of Self-sacrificing Love

Classics
So many classics have this timeless theme. As Deacon Pedro Guevara Mann and I talk about in this week’s podcast/TV segment, love is the timeless, universal human value present in all cultures. When we love as Jesus loves—a self-giving, self-sacrificing love—we are most truly ourselves, fulfilling our highest potential.

  • A Tale of Two Cities (1935’s version is my favorite, but there are many screen versions.) A very selfish character is transformed into a truly loving one.
  • Casablanca (1942) is one of my all-time favorite movies and still stands as one of the best films ever made. No spoilers here, but this film is also about an unlikely transformation and self-sacrifice.
  • Ben Hur (1959 version) My favorite Easter film. The main story follows the tragedy and ultimately conversion of Judah Ben Hur, whose life intersects with Christ’s. Ultimately Judah is transformed by witnessing Jesus’ Passion and Death.
  • To Kill a Mockingbird (1962) is a powerful look at how self-sacrificing love can confront and win over evil—in this case, the evil of racism.
  • Les Miserables (2018 mini-series is by far my favorite, but here is my post comparing screen versions, especially if you want to do a two- or three-hour version) ****
  • The original Star Wars Trilogy (1977, 1980, 1983) Luke’s character, as he transforms from a whiny teenager into a Jedi knight who, in the midst of trying to save the galaxy from the oppression of the Empire, doesn’t turn his back on trying to save the hopeless Darth Vader. The most recent films also highlight this theme of self-sacrifice through several characters. (The Mandalorian has a

 

Superheroes, Sci-fi, and Fantasy

Perhaps the definition of a hero includes being willing to take risks or sacrifice themselves for others. For most superheroes, this can involve risking/sacrificing one’s life, but even children can be heroic in putting others’ well-being before their own. These genres are full of the themes of self-sacrifice, even those superheroes who initially don’t seem to be very caring. If you have a favorite Superman or Batman film, add it to the list here!

  • Many of the Star Trek films: The early The Wrath of Khan (1982) is impressive in this regard, but my favorite example from the Star Trek universe is from the opening of the Star Trek movie reboot in 2009, in which a new father gives his life to protect 800 others.
  • The Iron Giant (1999) is notable and remains a friend’s all-time favorite.
  • Spirited Away (2001) is a Japanese animated classic that shows the transformation of a sulky youngster into a brave young woman determined to rescue her parents, despite the risks to herself.
  • Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Parts 1 and 2 (2010, 2011) Harry risks his life to save the school, his friends, or humanity—or all three!—in every film, but he deliberately does so in the last two films (which are really one big story).
  • The Avengers films (2008-2020…) One would need a whole website to discuss these films and the many superheroes who seek the good of others at great cost to themselves.
  • A Quiet Place (2018) This amazing thriller is one of the most recent films that powerfully demonstrates what it means to truly love.

Love Stories

Romances are supposed to be about love, but many times onscreen romantic relationships can seem to be more about using another person for one’s own fulfillment. “True love” may be a Disney cliche, but St. Paul gives us the characteristics of true love in 1 Corinthians 13: patient, kind, not envious or boastful or arrogant or rude, not insisting on its own way, not irritable or resentful, rejoicing not in wrongdoing but in the truth. Love “bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things. Love never fails.” (1 Cor. 13:4-8)

  • Titanic (1997) In the face of tragedy, close-ups of cowardice and heroic rescues.
  • Pride and Prejudice (the 1995 mini-series is my favorite, but take your pick from the many screen versions).
  • Beauty and the Beast (1991 or 2017 are the Disney classics, but Jean Cocteau’s 1946 version is another classic!) This popular love story begins with one selfless act of love and ends with two.
  • Twilight Saga (films series 2008-2012) Bella’s love for others is consistently self-sacrificing, even if the vampires sparkle in the sun.

Religious Films

  • Risen (2016) is the first full-length film about Jesus’ Resurrection. Joseph Fiennes is the Roman centurion ostensibly searching for Jesus’ body after his Crucifixion…but what is he really searching for, and what is he willing to sacrifice to find it?
  • The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe (2005), based on C. S. Lewis’ amazing Narnia series, is a wonderful Easter family film for the whole family.
  • The Lord of the Rings trilogy is full of characters who risk or give their lives to save others. From the powerful Gandalf to the humblest Sam, to the persevering Frodo. These three films are on my all-time favorites list.
  • The Chosen is the continuing TV series on the life of Jesus. (Note that the actor who plays Jesus is starring in an online version of the live play, The Last Days of Jesus Passion Play, which is currently available via streaming.)
  • Babette’s Feast (1987; with English subtitles) A contemplative look at a strict Christian community who take in a French refugee as a servant, Babette’s Feast is a powerful Eucharistic parable.

Some Recent Films:

  • Harriet (2019), which I just commented on last month, is a powerful film of faith and self-giving love.
  • A Hidden Life (2019) doesn’t just have the theme, but is about self-sacrificing love. (Here’s my earlier commentary.)
  • JoJo Rabbit (2019) The quirky, tragic treatment of the height of World War II in Nazi Germany as seen through the eyes of a young German boy contains some surprising heroism.
  • Even the recent Abominable (2019) contains elements of self-giving love!

Everyday Heroism (Miscellaneous)

I have run out of time to add more categories, but I can’t skip these amazing films.

  • Marvin’s Room (1996) This powerful film about transformation, family, and sisters, doesn’t just give us countless examples of self-sacrificing love, but also show what a gift it is to have loved.
  • Finest Hours (2016) The based-on-a-true story heroics of members of the Coast Guard who try a daring rescue in the midst of a blizzard.

…and so many more.

So during this season, I’d like to challenge you to look for glimmers or reflections of God’s love in the films that inspire you.

I’d love to add to this list… If you’d like to send me suggestions—for now via email, but I’ll also try to check in to my Facebook page—I’ll add them.

Harriet: A Tiny Woman with a Towering Faith

 

Harriet is one of the most inspiring biopics that I have seen in a long time  (apart from A Hidden Life). Co-written by director Kasi Lemmons and producer Gregory Allen Howard, the film chronicles Harriet Tubman’s desperate escape to freedom and then her dangerous journeys back as a conductor in the Underground Railroad—covering about 10 years of her life. Refreshingly, the film doesn’t try to deny or hide Harriet’s spirituality: she is known as Moses by the slave community, because she brings slaves to the promised land of freedom. I suspect a lot of viewers are like myself and don’t know much about Harriet Tubman, so my comments will be brief to avoid too many spoilers. (In this week’s Salt + Light Radio Hour, my commentary is just about one minute long–no spoilers!)

Cynthia Erivo is simply marvelous as Harriet, portraying emotions of terror, desperation, and righteous anger, while still carrying herself with remarkable conviction and dignity. Several of the minor characters in the film are fictional but overall the film is quite accurate in its portrayal of Harriet Tubman herself: a tiny woman of towering courage and determination who overcame overwhelming obstacles to build a new life for herself and to bring others—especially members of her family—to freedom.

Despite its PG-13 rating, Harriet would be an excellent film for families with teens and even some pre-teens who are mature enough to watch a film about slavery. A couple scenes with brutal violence are difficult to watch, especially for a sensitive younger person, but for the most part, the most disturbing violence is offscreen.

Windows to the Soul

Harriet Tubman suffered a severe head injury as a child, which seems to have caused brain damage. This injury was blamed for her “fits,” when she would fall to the ground and be unresponsive to the world around her, having dreams or “visions.” Harriet, who was deeply religious, often heard a message from God in her “visions.” In a welcome authenticity, the film imaginatively portrays Harriet’s religious experience. How refreshing it is to see filmmakers recognize the role of faith—or at least the possibility of the miraculous—in Harriet’s life, without discrediting or dismissing it. Harriet herself credited her repeated miraculous escapes to guidance from the Lord.

Harriet is a powerful film that engages on many levels, including the spiritual. It is a great film for Lent because Lent is meant to be its own journey to freedom—allowing the Lord to lead us and set us free from the sins that enslave us.

Themes to reflect on and pray with: faith, freedom, slavery, the dignity of the human person, racism, family, fidelity vs. betrayal, living by conviction, social justice.

I AM PATRICK docudrama reveals the true St. Patrick

I AM PATRICK is an excellent feature-length docudrama about the life of one of my favorite saints, the Apostle to Ireland. Written and directed by Jarrod Anderson and produced by CBN Films, the film is based on St. Patrick’s own Confession. The dramatic parts are well-acted, including the segments with John Rhys-Davies, where he is writing his Confession. I wish he had had a bigger role!

The interviews are well-done with a good mix of experts; the flow back and forth between interviews, narration, and dramatized scenes take us through the life of Saint Patrick in an overall linear fashion. The focus here is not on the legends and miracles, but the life of St. Patrick from his own words, which has plenty of drama in itself: he was kidnapped and enslaved at age 16; dramatically escaped after six years; heard God’s call in a dream to return to Ireland as a missionary; and evangelized Ireland under very difficult and hostile circumstances, at times risking his life to share the Good News of Jesus Christ.

For the most part, the film’s interpretation of Patrick’s life seems quite accurate. (I researched the life of Saint Patrick for a chapter in one of my books on the saints.) The only nuance I would dispute is found near the end of the film, when Patrick’s integrity, and perhaps his authority as bishop, is being questioned by a couple other bishops. In his Confession, Patrick doesn’t provide specifics, neither why he was being questioned nor how the situation was resolved. What he does make clear is that he was vindicated. However, the film seems to give Patrick a rather individualistic vibe, as if Patrick simply rebelled against the other bishops and went his own way. But to be in communion with the Church would have been very important to Patrick, and he would have wanted his new converts in Ireland to be in communion with the Church.

Check out my comments on I AM PATRICK on Salt + Light’s Radio Hour here. 

As the docudrama of a life of a saint, I AM PATRICK is remarkably well-done, with insightful interviews, well-acted drama, and narration that offers a helpful historical perspective. The quotations from Patrick’s Confession don’t just provide a remarkable authenticity, but are particularly moving in revealing St. Patrick’s depth of emotion, passion for Christ, and conviction for evangelization. Watching this docudrama is an informative delight, both for those who don’t know Saint Patrick well (or only through popular legends) or those who would like to deepen their knowledge of the real Saint Patrick’s life and mission. 

By the way, if you are interested in going right to the Saint Patrick’s own words to learn more about him, English translations of his Confession and his Letter to Coroticus can be found for free online. I include below the prayer I wrote to Saint Patrick for Saints Alive! The Gospel Witnessed.

I AM PATRICK is releasing theatrically in theaters in the USA for just two days, March 17 & 18. Seeing this film is a great way to truly celebrate Saint Patrick’s Day, whether you are able to see it in theaters for its theatrical release, or you keep an eye out for its streaming/DVD release. For more information and to find tickets, visit  https://www.iampatrick.com/  

Prayer to Saint Patrick

St. Patrick,
you suffered greatly in your life:
kidnapping, loss of family, slavery, isolation, and betrayal.
Your sufferings did not embitter you
but brought you to a deeper relationship with Christ
and gave you great compassion for others who suffered.
Have pity on those who suffer violence and slavery in our own day.
Teach us to allow the Spirit to pray in us,
so that we too can witness to the Gospel
by living the spirit of forgiveness
and loving with the heart of Christ.
Amen.

 

Masterpiece “A Hidden Life” Reveals the Mysticism of the Cross

In my opinion, the best film of 2019 was barely acknowledged throughout the awards season. A Hidden Life is a magnificent masterpiece from almost any perspective, a biopic of a seemingly very ordinary man and his wife and their tragic but ultimately triumphant decision to take a stand against one of history’s most evil regimes. A Hidden Life is a timely story for our day when following one’s conscience against prevailing sentiment is admired but seems quite rare.

In my Windows to the Soul segment on the Salt + Light Radio Hour last week, I couldn’t restrain my enthusiasm for A Hidden Life: a film made by a brilliant filmmaker about a future saint of the Catholic Church. (Franz Jägerstätter, a peasant Austrian farmer who was executed for refusing to serve in the Nazi army and take an oath to Hitler, was beatified by Pope Benedict XVI as a martyr in 2007.) Rather than offering a detailed commentary here, I will share what I especially loved about A Hidden Life after just one viewing. (I fully intend to watch it again when it releases to streaming/DVD in March. At that point, I will put together a Cinema Divina Guide that you can use on your own or perhaps with your family or a group.)

Director/writer Terrence Malick has had a distinguished career as a filmmaker, with his work often described as visual poetry. I am no expert on Malick’s films as I have only seen about half of them. But many people who watch one of his films for the first time have a strong reaction to it—loving it or hating it. His films are always visually impressive, offering depth, raising powerful questions and providing an opportunity for reflection. Despite its length (just 6 minutes short of three hours), A Hidden Life is one of his most accessible recent films, as it follows a linear narrative that cannot help but evoke strong emotion.

A Brave Choice

Exploring the life of an ordinary man who made one extraordinary decision was a courageous choice for filmmaker Terrence Malick. Just one sentence can capture the story of Blessed Franz Jägerstätter: a young Austrian farmer who followed his conscience, refused to serve in the Nazi army, and was executed for it in 1943, leaving behind his wife and young daughters. In the hands of another filmmaker, this could have been a boring, “preachy,” or superficial film. But not here. There’s no preaching. I don’t believe the film even uses the word “conscience” once.

With Franz’s one surprising decision as his focal point, Malick gives us an authentic, compellingly human portrayal of the heartbreak of an ordinary couple committed to following Christ. At the same time, the film unpacks the grand themes of conscience, discernment, family, free will, suffering, and martyrdom (in several forms), but all in a very human, natural way. A Hidden Life has little (if any) cerebral dialogue and no grandstanding shots or speeches. Instead, sparse dialogue, phenomenal acting, and tender scenes of daily life amidst an inexorable buildup of tension enable us to enter into the lives of Franz and Fani and the mystery of what it meant for them to truly follow Christ even to the point of death.

A Contemplative Experience

A Hidden Life is not a spectacle film full of explosions or fights, but it is a spectacular film, with its sweeping vistas of the mountainside that, combined with the scenes of ordinary farm labor and visual details of intimate family moments, immerse us in the Jägerstätter family life. The film heightens the tension by its use of endless contrasts—between light and dark, truth and illusion, the sloped cathedral of nature and the torment of closed prison walls.

Like many of Malick’s films, A Hidden Life is not just visual storytelling, but uses every cinematic element to help us enter into an experience: haunting music, visual beauty, personal details, authentic performances, historical accuracy, tenderly moving letters between husband and wife, and understated but rising narrative tension. That is the greatness of A Hidden Life: as every element of the film helps us enter into the inner drama of Franz and Fani, we are able to share just a bit in the mystery of their Christ-like, heroic choices to love.

The rhythm of the film is contemplative, with some similarities to another great film, Of Gods and Men (the story of the Trappist monks who were martyred in Algeria in 1996.)  A Hidden Life has a clear, linear narrative that brings Franz, Fani, and us relentlessly towards an end we might dread but need to see: how could they possibly endure? Each moment of the film—including its exquisite backdrop of skies, mountains, and farm life—is layered with purpose and meaning that deepen our understanding. The skies, the mountain, the farm, the little church, all seem to be characters who witness to the agonizing drama of two ordinary souls being shaped to heroic love.

An Exploration of Christian Discipleship

The portrayal of a deeply loving marriage is one of the strengths of this film—artistically and as a recognition of the spouses of those who make heroic choices. Although Fani and Franz are far from perfect, the film offers a rare screen-model for Catholic marriage. Husband and wife are clearly individuals with normal joys, sufferings, and tensions (Franz’s mother resents Fani and blames her for Franz’s choice). They do not agree on everything but nevertheless, love each other so much that they always choose to support the other. Fani clearly struggles with the consequences of the choice Franz makes, and in the film, Fani’s journey is as important as Franz’s. Franz clearly relies on her strength, understanding, and above all her love, as the inevitability of his martyrdom approaches. Her “martyrdom” is of a different sort, but she fully shares in his suffering as she is left alone, a widow who, isolated and despised by most of the villagers, must work a farm and raise three young daughters.

The sparseness of the dialogue initially builds the tension in the film, as it allows us to imagine the interior sufferings of Franz and Fani. Eventually, though, words become less and less necessary; and the words that are used take on great depth of meaning, as they are excerpts from the letters between the couple. (The letters are available in English in Orbis’ edition of Franz Jägerstätter: Letters and Writings from Prison.)

A Hidden Life is sacred art at its most glorious, a cinematic masterpiece by a renowned and brilliant filmmaker that takes us on a journey through the details of an ordinary Christian life and beyond: into both the human agony and hope-filled mysticism of the Cross. A Hidden Life is so much more than a movie to watch: it is a powerful experience not to be missed, a journey that takes us deep into some of the most important questions and themes of our time: the dignity of the individual and of free will, the critical importance of following one’s conscience, the gift of discernment, the strength that comes from the love of family, what it means to be faithful to Christ and to one’s loved ones, insights on Christian suffering, and what martyrdom looks like today, in a time when discipleship and living according to our conscience is challenged by the culture in which we live. Over and over again, Franz is badgered with the question, “What difference will your choice make if someone else will just take your place?”

A Hidden Life is an artistic triumph and an impressively authentic biopic of a martyr and his wife who are faithful not just to Christ but to each other. But above all, it is a meditation, a movie for the soul. A Hidden Life is a film not to be missed, an excellent choice to watch especially in these weeks of Lent and Easter.

You can learn more about the lives of Franz and Fani through their letters, the out-of-print biography In Solitary Witness by Gordon Zahn, or watching the half-hour documentary, Franz Jägerstätter: A Man of Conscience.

“Two Popes” Film Commentary: Stereotypes Win Over Depth

 

Netflix’s The Two Popes is a strange mix of fact and fiction, craftsmanship and lack of research or understanding. The film, which received three Oscar nominations (best actor for Jonathan Pryce’s performance as Cardinal Bergoglio, best supporting actor for Anthony Hopkins as Pope Benedict, and best adapted screenplay by well-respected biopic screenwriter Anthony McCarten), centers around an imaginary encounter that takes place between the soon-to-be Pope Francis and Pope Benedict XVI before he announces his retirement. For those who are more familiar with both popes, the shallow portrayal of Pope Benedict is not just disappointing but so false that it detracts from the story’s believability, while the portrayal of Cardinal Bergoglio has much more depth and sympathy, including several flashbacks to significant events in his earlier life. In many respects, the film feels like a tribute to Pope Francis; unfortunately, it does this by contrasting him favorably with a “straw man” version of Pope Benedict—someone who is just a shadow of the real man and pope. For those less familiar with the Church and the individual popes, the film could easily reinforce unhelpful stereotypes of the Church and both popes.

For an in-depth conversation on The Two Popes, check out Salt + Light Radio’s Special with Deacon Pedro Guevara-Mann and Sr. Marie Paul. 

The film has many strong points artistically: strong performances and high production values with details in the costumes and sets that made me wonder if the filmmakers had somehow gotten inside the Vatican, especially the impressive reproduction of the Sistine Chapel. The close-up camera work gives an intimate feel to the story.

The two well-known actors who play the leads—Jonathan Pryce as Cardinal Bergoglio and Anthony Hopkins as Pope Benedict—both received Oscar nominations for their performances. It is to their credit that they carry the majority of the film with their dialogue, a reflection of the film’s stage-play origins. Although a few lines made me smile, overall the script lacked nuance and in-depth research. For much of the first half of the film, the dialogue focuses on the few topics that the media often assume are most important (or at least more controversial), rather than the grave concerns that both real popes have brought to the fore as most urgent to the Church and the world today. And while some of the lines of dialogue are the actual words of Pope Francis or the Pope Emeritus, they are taken out of context. A poorly researched script and story such as this doesn’t deserve to begin with the words, “Inspired by true events,” even taking into account the conventions of cinema and the needs of drama.

Jonathan Pryce’s portrayal of Pope Francis quite convincing, imitating Pope Francis’ mannerisms and projecting an openness to others that feels genuine. Hopkins gives a good performance, portraying a gradual transformation from a leader who is elderly, rigid, and “out of touch”  to someone who re-learns how to joke and trust. But this portrayal is so far from what we know of the real Pope Benedict XVI (who is well known as a soft-spoken scholar whose massive gifts of intellect, insight, and passion for Christ are enhanced by his gentle manner and clarity of expression). The portrayal is not only unflattering but is also so unlike the real Pope Emeritus that it detracts from the ending of communion and reconciliation that is the high point of the film.

Because the film mixes actual footage and some accurate information with an imaginary encounter between the two churchmen, it could be hard for most viewers to distinguish what is blatantly inaccurate or untrue. An initial example: the film shows Anthony Hopkins actively seeking election to become pope, when we know that, even before his election as pope, the real Cardinal Ratzinger asked Pope St. John Paul to retire more than once.

In addition, the uneven treatment of the two popes makes for a much poorer story. By setting up a superficial disagreement or antagonism between the two characters, the filmmakers are not just unfair to both real popes (who are both great churchmen who have contributed so much to the Church and the world). The filmmakers lose the creative opportunity for telling a deeper, more dramatic story free of stereotypes: that of two spiritually mature men who have both dedicated their lives to Christ, who approach the needs of the world and the Church in contrasting (not contradictory) ways.

The film’s portrayal of Cardinal Bergoglio has some depth and sympathetic moments, where Hopkins’ Pope Benedict is superficial: a cranky old man who needs this one encounter with Bergoglio to hear the voice of God. The filmmakers’ bias toward Pope Francis is most clearly revealed in the decision to show several flashbacks of two key moments in Bergoglio’s early life, while the film offers no flashbacks for Pope Benedict. This decision gives the audience no opportunity to develop a deeper sympathy for the difficulties Pope Benedict faced in his early life. It also makes obvious that this film is meant to be a sympathetic tribute to Pope Francis, which would be more convincing if it were more accurate in both portrayals, especially of Pope Emeritus Benedict. In a few early moments in the film, the actor playing Cardinal Bergoglio seems to poke fun at customs of Hopkins’ Pope Benedict; this is a disservice to both real popes: a deep respect for all cultures has been quite important to the real Pope Francis.

Windows to the Soul?

However, the value of the film (as well as evidence of the filmmakers’ goodwill) is evident in the development of the story itself. If we lift the dialogue out of these characters’ mouths and place it in another situation, in other mouths, then the film offers some helpful insights into how honesty, respectful dialogue, a commitment to Christ, and the Sacrament of Reconciliation can lead to deeper communion and a unified approach to doing what is best for the world and the Church. I found it helpful to listen to the dialogue as representing various voices in the Church and culture, with different concerns and emphases. In our society today that often focuses on extremism and intolerance for those who believe differently and hold different values, The Two Popes points to a path of reconciliation and communion.

Ultimately, despite its Oscar nomination for best adapted screenplay, The Two Popes lacks the depth and authenticity that would make this a well-done biopic, or even an adequate depiction. The likelihood that many people who see it will either not take the time to sort fact from fiction (or error), or will simply accept the stereotypes, is problematic. At the same time, The Two Popes is an interesting portrayal of the Church from not-so-well-informed but somewhat sympathetic secular media makers. The power and beauty of the spirituality of encounter, so essential to Pope Francis’ entire papacy, is well represented here. And perhaps that is the film’s true tribute to Pope Francis.

For contrasting and thoughtful commentaries on The Two Popes, see Bishop Barron’s The One Pope and Sr. Nancy Usselman’s take, The Two Popes—Growing in Communion. For a “Vatican insider’s” perspective on the film’s accuracy, check out The Two Popes: Baloney, Brilliantly Acted by George Weigel.

The Farewell Movie Commentary: Tribute to Family

 

I feel privileged I was able to watch The Farewell during November (the month where the liturgy encourages us to reflect on the Last Things, as well as a strong family time with Thanksgiving), and especially this week, when my community is grieving the death of one of our elderly sisters, as well as two close brothers from the Society of Saint Paul. The Farewell is a well-crafted, understated and moving tribute to family, the elderly, grief, and the importance of respect for cultural differences.

The Farewell’s story revolves around Billi, a young Chinese American woman who discovers that her grandmother has advanced cancer. The twist? That her family back in China have decided not to tell her, and instead stage a family wedding as an excuse for family members to come and visit the grandmother one last time.

Listen to my commentary on The Farewell on the Salt + Light Radio Hour here.

The Farewell contains both laugh-out-loud and cry-out-loud moments in this dramedy. I admire the filmmakers and actors, especially director Lulu Wang (upon whose family this story is based) and actress Awkwafina, for being unafraid to sit with the characters as they grieve the upcoming loss of Nai Nai (Mandarin for grandmother). In the midst of sorrow, the film also showcases the true-to-life comedy of family members trying to help each other keep the family secret.

The choice of music adds significantly to the pathos of the film, even during the credits. “Come Healing,” by Leonard Cohen, sung during the credits, felt like a prayer and provides much to meditate on as the film ends.

The outstanding authenticity of this film—“based on an actual lie” is the tagline—was fought for by writer/director Lulu Wang, who brilliantly and subtly communicates the beauties and challenges of the immigrant Chinese-American experience. The acting and directing are both superb, and the script is exquisite in its realistic dialogue that also gives us a few peak moments of wisdom—much like conversation in everyday life. One favorite line is a little saying from Nai Nai, “Life is not just about what you do, it’s more about how you do it.” And the cultural wisdom offered by the Chinese elders who talk about how family should bear burdens that might overwhelm a vulnerable individual is a beautiful insight into what family is all about.

The film’s worldview is intercultural, with moments of the family comparing life in the USA and China, but lacking any direct reference to the beliefs and practice of Christianity. Yet, this flawed and loving family make beautifully evident the grace of God at work in the genuinely human experiences of their lives.

The Farewell lacks the sensationalized entertainment values of many films today, but is the richer for it. This is a movie to watch for those who wish to be deeply moved and enter into an intense human experience of family. Subtitles and the sometimes intensely sorrowful moments in the film make The Farewell more appropriate for thoughtful viewers able to discern the nuances of family, loss, and family secrets. Although rated PG, this may not be the best choice for pre- and young teens, but would be a great film for older family members and movie groups to watch and discuss together. And…make sure you watch to the end!

Themes: Family, grief, terminal illness, secrets, intercultural differences.

For another thoughtful review (with spoilers), check out Sr. Nancy Usselmann’s take on The Farewell.